Proactive vs Reactive: Which Way to Success?

A leader’s ability to guide teams and navigate challenges is often defined by their management style. At the core of good leadership is the choice between two approaches: proactive and reactive management. While both have their place, understanding the difference will help corporate leaders refine their approach and win in today’s fast-paced business world.
Share the Post:

What are Proactive and Reactive Management?

Proactive Management

Proactive managers see the problems and opportunities before they happen. By looking at past trends and predicting future scenarios they create plans to deal with those situations. This approach is about preparation and foresight so operations run smoothly and with minimal disruptions.

Reactive Management

Reactive managers respond to issues as they happen. They may not see every problem coming but their strength is in being able to adapt and resolve crises quickly. This approach requires quick thinking and flexibility, especially in uncertain environments.

The difference between Proactive vs Reactive

The main difference is timing. Proactive leaders act before an issue arises, and reactive leaders respond after an issue has occurred. Let’s use a procurement example:
  • A proactive procurement manager reviews historical data, sees seasonal trends in supply costs and buys in early. When market prices spike their organisation is unaffected, they remain efficient and cost-effective.
  • A reactive procurement manager on the other hand waits until supplies are low to act. If demand surges unexpectedly they scramble to meet the need, often at a higher cost or with shortages.

Advantages and disadvantages of Proactive and Reactive Management

Proactive Management: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Reduces risk by seeing the problem.
  • Improves long-term planning and resource allocation.
  • Builds a culture of innovation and preparedness.

Cons:

  • Takes a lot of time and effort to plan.
  • May do unnecessary work if the problem doesn’t materialise.

Reactive Management: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Can adapt to unexpected events.
  • Suitable for fast-paced industries where quick responses are critical.
  • Encourages problem-solving under pressure.

Cons:

  • More likely to be inefficient and wasteful.
  • Can lead to team burnout from constant crisis management?

Proactive and Reactive Leadership in real life

In business

  • Proactive: A company creates a detailed contingency plan to mitigate risks from supply chain disruption.
  • Reactive: Another company waits until a supplier doesn’t deliver and then looks for alternative sources under a tight deadline.

In customer service

  • Proactive: Anticipate common customer issues and provide self-service online.
  • Reactive: Only respond to customer complaints when they contact you.

Proactive and Reactive styles of decision making

Proactive leaders make strategic decisions, their teams work towards long term goals with clarity. Reactive leaders are good at crisis management but often make decisions under pressure which can compromise long term goals. Balancing both styles will improve decision making.

From Reactive to Proactive Leadership

To become proactive you need to develop habits that encourage forward thinking. Here’s how:
  1. Use prioritisation tools: Use frameworks to focus on tasks that prevent future problems.
  2. Encourage team collaboration: Create an environment where team members can see the problem together.
  3. Invest in training: Leadership development for yourself and your team to identify and mitigate risks early.
  4. Leverage technology: Use data analytics and predictive tools to forecast trends and plan.

Tools and Resources for Proactive Leaders

  • Planning Software: Asana or Trello to map out detailed plans.
  • Training Programs: Peeplcoach leadership programs on strategic leadership.
  • Data analytics platforms: Software to forecast trends and inform decisions.

Myths About Proactive and Reactive Leadership

  • Proactive means perfect: Not every proactive strategy will prevent every problem. Success is about minimising risk not eliminating it altogether.
  • Reactive leadership is useless: In high pressure situations, reactive approaches are essential.
As AI and predictive analytics become more common the lines between proactive and reactive management will disappear. Leaders will use technology to anticipate problems and make informed decisions and blend both styles together.

Be Proactive

Becoming a proactive leader starts with small steps. Get the right tools, develop a forward-thinking mindset and empower your team to see the problems. Talk with us today and set yourself and your team up for long-term success in your organisation.

Sign-up to our newsletter.

Wherever you are in your career, first job, first time leader or leadership guru each month The Pulse will share a 5 min leadership or career hack to help you amplify your professional, team or business impact.

Short and sharp, the Pulse is focused on getting to the heart of the matter, because we know you don’t have a lot of time.

Fostering the Growth of
High-performing Leaders.

Discover how we are partnering with other organisations and making an impact for businesses and individuals.

Scott Thompson

Agnel Dsouza

Jo Hart

Jo Hart is the Chief Operating Officer at Peeplcoach, where she focuses on optimising the systems and processes that drive the delivery of accessible, high-quality coaching.

With over 23 years of experience, Jo’s career has spanned finance, operations, project management, optimisation, learning and development, and leading project teams. She has worked both locally and internationally, supporting organisations in achieving efficiency and effectiveness across industries such as financial services, health services, information technology, insurance, media, and retail.

Jo has held significant roles at Deutsche Bank, Adecco Group, and the Australian Association of Social Workers. Known for her love of challenges, Jo is dedicated to contributing to her team’s efforts in delivering development opportunities that enhance engagement and help people and organisations reach their full potential.

Richard Clarke

Greer O’Brien

Joanne Hall

Richard Tootill

Richard is the Sales Manager at Peeplcoach, bringing over 10 years of experience in solution sales across leadership development and coaching, recruitment, and SaaS technologies within the IT and digital space. He has worked in various environments, including global corporates, fast-growing companies, and start-ups, with a career that includes roles at Oracle, Seek, and Elmo Software. Richard has primarily focused on driving new business in the B2B space, working with some of Australia’s most well-known organisations, including Fortescue Metals Group, Multiplex, Commonwealth Bank, Arup, and Austrade, to name a few.

In all his roles, Richard’s passion lies in solving challenges for both individuals and organisations, helping people be the best they can be. His goal is to help organisations succeed and empower individuals to reach their full potential by finding what they love to do.

Richard also holds a Bachelor of Business from Griffith University (QLD), majoring in sports management.

Michael Rainey

Michael is the Projects Manager at Peeplcoach, responsible for ensuring seamless operations across various processes, from launching new coachees on the platform to onboarding Peeplcoach coaches and introducing new content.

With over 25 years of experience, Michael’s career has spanned roles in finance, human resources, training, learning, and organisational development. He has contributed to the success of organisations such as CBA, Mercedes-Benz, Lumo Energy, Yarra Valley Water, and Bendigo Kangan Institute of TAFE. Michael holds a Bachelor of Education & Training, a Bachelor of Psychological Science (Honours), a Graduate Certificate in Human Resource Management, and a Graduate Diploma in Psychological Studies.

His mission is to develop and enable others, equipping them with the tools they need to reach their full potential while driving the organisation’s success.

Email: Michael.Rainey@peeplcoach.com

Faydra Khor

Zana Ballantyne

Zana is both a Master Coach and the Head of Coaches at Peeplcoach. In her role, she is responsible for recruiting, growing, developing, leading, and inspiring a team of passionate and talented coaches, all dedicated to making coaching accessible to everyone.

She currently leads a team that supports emerging and developing leaders across Australia, New Zealand, the US, the UK, Singapore, and India. With over 25 years of experience in people development and leadership across continents, Zana is renowned for driving people-led organisational change and cultivating positive cultures. Her expertise includes working with various levels of leadership in industries such as GE, Coles, ADP, Consumer Affairs, and Ambulance Victoria, with notable clients including Asahi, Dulux, Inghams, Latrobe City Council, and Bega.

Zana holds a Post Graduate Certificate in Organisational Coaching and is a qualified practitioner and facilitator in DISC, LSI, GSI, NLP, MBTI, and Change Acceleration Process (PCI). As a leader and coach, she excels in uncovering hidden challenges and empowering individuals to find actionable solutions. Her approach prioritizes building capability, creating high-performing teams, and driving sustainable business results through people-first strategies.

Virginia Aldred

Vanessa Jones

Susan Williams

Sean O’Leary

Sarah Bateman

Rob Watson

Natalie Hormann

Margaret Haarhoff

Kaye Brett

Karin Moorhouse

Joanna Clary

Jinn Kan

Jillian Bolger

Jess Ferguson

James Chisholm

James Chisholm is the Co-Founder and Executive Coach at Peeplcoach. He brings over 25 years of business leadership experience performing roles in executive general management, board directorship, business development, leadership coaching, team facilitation and operational leadership. His career has covered multiple industries including building technology services, asset management, renewable energy and not-for-profit with large multi-national corporations, private companies and SMEs including Honeywell and WATCH Disability Services. 

With extensive local and international experience, James has led teams of up to thousands of employees across varied countries and cultures and enjoys working with diverse groups of people to achieve outcomes with a sense of purpose and alignment with his personal values. In addition to his leadership and executive coaching work, James frequently facilitates leadership and executive team sessions where constructive culture and high performance are the desired outcomes.

Hilary Gustave

Felicity Brown

Evie Suss

Dr Simone Boer

Doug Binns

Dianne Flemington

Di Kanagalingam

Bryan Carroll

Charlotte Rush

Christine Khor

Christine Khor is CEO, Founder and Lead Coach at Peeplcoach and is passionate about the role that coaching has in accelerating performance for individuals, teams and organisations and making Peeplcoach the best leadership coaching platform she can!

Before becoming an executive coach and launching Peeplcaoch, Christine started her career In marketing management with global organisations such as Kraft Foods, Hallmark Cards and Simplot Australia.

After a successful career leading teams, Christine started the recruitment and executive search company Chorus Executive where she has partnered with hundreds of organisations and thousands of individuals offering recruitment, search and business, career and executive coaching services. In 2020 launched Peeplcoach with the mission to make coaching accessible to all employees within an organisation, not executives only.

As an executive coach at Peeplcoach, Christine partners with all levels of employees within an organisation from emerging leaders to executives. With her c-suite and start-up business and leadership experience Christine brings a commercial and pragmatic approach to her coaching sessions. Christine holds several qualifications including a Bachelor of Arts, Master of Business Administration, Post Graduate Diploma in Policy Studies and Graduate Diploma in Organisational Change and Executive Coaching.

Clare Phelan

Dawn James

Deb McDonald

Bronwyn Rose

Anne Basia

Anglea Zegir